PJ Horgan, Class of 1984

PJ Horgan’s tenure at Peddie was defined by his dedication and versatility. He excelled in not just one, but three sports — football, basketball and baseball. A previous Hall of Fame inductee with the 1982-1983 baseball team, Horgan was instrumental in the success of the 1982-1983 NJISAA Prep ‘A’ Championship baseball team. “Whenever we walked on the field, I believed we were going to win,” he recalled.

Horgan also played three years of varsity basketball and football, and he competed in winter track during his senior year. His football teammate Rich Rebh ’84 remembered Horgan’s grit and determination, recounting a critical play against Blair that defined their senior year.

When a botched snap threatened a scoring attempt, Horgan’s quick thinking turned the situation into a touchdown, securing a 22-20 victory. This moment of quick decision-making not only secured a win but also inspired his teammates. “That one play was the catalyst of that whole game and defined our entire senior year,” said Rebh.

Reflecting on his time at Peddie, Horgan expressed gratitude for the strong foundation it provided. “Traditional team sports are really the centerpiece for life learning skills,” he said.